The all-time table uses three points for a win and one point for a draw, and does not consider point deductions

Rank	Team	Seasons	G	W	D	L	GF	GA	Pts	Pts/Game	+-	+-/game	Champions	Relegated
1	Tadcaster Albion	4	168	110	28	30	431	204	358	2.1310	227	1.3512	1	0
2	Bridlington Town	4	168	96	28	44	400	244	316	1.8810	156	0.9286	0	0
3	Barton Town Old Boys	4	168	90	30	48	374	239	300	1.7857	135	0.8036	0	0
4	Pickering Town	4	168	90	22	56	388	278	292	1.7381	110	0.6548	0	0
5	Thackley	4	168	70	30	68	310	313	240	1.4286	-3	-0.0179	0	0
6	Staveley Miners Welfare	4	168	68	27	73	304	311	231	1.3750	-7	-0.0417	0	0
7	Retford United	4	168	63	31	74	276	337	220	1.3095	-61	-0.3631	0	0
8	Maltby Main	4	168	64	20	84	298	356	212	1.2619	-58	-0.3452	0	0
9	Heanor Town	3	126	65	14	47	289	208	209	1.6587	81	0.6429	0	0
10	Albion Sports	3	126	61	15	50	282	223	198	1.5714	59	0.4683	0	0
11	Brighouse Town	2	86	62	12	12	244	96	198	2.3023	148	1.7209	1	0
12	Parkgate	4	168	52	29	87	246	323	185	1.1012	-77	-0.4583	0	0
13	Worksop Town	2	82	54	11	17	244	98	173	2.1098	146	1.7805	0	0
14	Cleethorpes Town	2	82	53	9	20	213	98	168	2.0488	115	1.4024	0	0
15	Handsworth Parramore	2	82	51	15	16	203	98	168	2.0488	105	1.2805	0	0
16	Athersley Recreation	3	126	48	21	57	207	234	165	1.3095	-27	-0.2143	0	0
17	Worksop Parramore	2	86	50	14	22	203	131	164	1.9070	72	0.8372	0	0
18	Liversedge	4	168	43	34	91	233	382	163	0.9702	-149	-0.8869	0	0
19	Garforth Town	3	126	42	25	59	208	227	151	1.1984	-19	-0.1508	0	0
20	Armthorpe Welfare	4	168	39	32	97	236	410	149	0.8869	-174	-1.0357	0	0
21	Long Eaton United	2	86	39	12	35	157	148	129	1.5000	9	0.1047	0	0
22	Nostell Miners Welfare	4	168	33	25	110	195	428	124	0.7381	-233	-1.3869	0	1
23	Glasshoughton Welfare	3	126	31	19	76	151	342	112	0.8889	-191	-1.5159	0	1
24	Scarborough Athletic	1	42	30	9	3	129	49	99	2.3571	80	1.9048	1	0
25	Shaw Lane	1	40	29	7	4	130	33	94	2.3500	97	2.4250	1	0
26	Basford United	1	44	26	6	12	97	57	84	1.9091	40	0.9091	0	0
27	Rainworth Miners Welfare	1	42	19	6	17	98	81	63	1.5000	17	0.4048	0	0
28	Winterton Rangers	2	86	14	13	59	83	221	55	0.6395	-138	-1.6047	0	1
29	Clipstone	1	42	15	10	17	85	70	55	1.3095	15	0.3571	0	0
30	Arnold Town	1	42	14	3	25	65	93	45	1.0714	-28	-0.6667	0	1
31	Pontefract Collieries	1	42	11	6	25	60	110	39	0.9286	-50	-1.1905	0	1
32	Brigg Town	1	42	10	7	25	49	103	37	0.8810	-54	-1.2857	0	1
33	Lincoln Moorlands Railway	2	86	9	9	68	69	350	36	0.4186	-281	-3.2674	0	1
34	Hall Road Rangers	1	42	7	5	30	52	114	26	0.6190	-62	-1.4762	0	1