The all-time table uses three points for a win and one point for a draw, and does not consider point deductions

Rank	Team	Seasons	G	W	D	L	GF	GA	Pts	Pts/Game	+-	+-/game	Champions	Relegated
1	Ashton United	9	374	182	94	98	729	496	640	1.7112	233	0.6230	0	0
2	Farsley Celtic	11	458	171	121	166	694	752	634	1.3843	-58	-0.1266	0	0
3	Radcliffe	9	374	174	90	110	669	504	612	1.6364	165	0.4412	1	0
4	Lincoln United	9	376	156	96	124	642	595	564	1.5000	47	0.1250	0	0
5	Kendal Town	11	458	145	102	211	625	748	537	1.1725	-123	-0.2686	0	0
6	Eastwood Town	10	416	139	105	172	552	618	522	1.2548	-66	-0.1587	0	1
7	Workington	10	416	129	105	182	560	664	492	1.1827	-104	-0.2500	0	1
8	Matlock Town	8	336	133	78	125	499	475	477	1.4196	24	0.0714	0	0
9	Gretna	9	374	125	95	154	575	633	470	1.2567	-58	-0.1551	0	0
10	Witton Albion	7	294	128	86	80	486	388	470	1.5986	98	0.3333	0	0
11	Harrogate Town	9	374	121	89	164	542	665	452	1.2086	-123	-0.3289	1	0
12	Stocksbridge Park Steels	8	336	122	82	132	506	547	448	1.3333	-41	-0.1220	0	0
13	Bradford Park Avenue	6	250	115	58	77	401	311	403	1.6120	90	0.3600	1	0
14	Belper Town	7	294	105	79	110	402	423	394	1.3401	-21	-0.0714	0	0
15	Alfreton Town	5	206	101	43	62	415	311	346	1.6796	104	0.5049	1	1
16	Congleton Town	8	332	87	83	162	424	625	344	1.0361	-201	-0.6054	0	1
17	Worksop Town	5	206	97	50	59	419	327	341	1.6553	92	0.4466	0	0
18	Guiseley	5	208	88	51	69	318	261	315	1.5144	57	0.2740	1	0
19	Trafford	6	252	81	56	115	341	425	299	1.1865	-84	-0.3333	0	1
20	Chorley	5	210	78	58	74	317	312	292	1.3905	5	0.0238	0	0
21	Ossett Town	5	210	77	52	81	317	310	283	1.3476	7	0.0333	0	0
22	Great Harwood Town	6	248	69	66	113	314	432	273	1.1008	-118	-0.4758	0	1
23	Bamber Bridge	4	166	69	42	55	282	222	249	1.5000	60	0.3614	0	0
24	Spennymoor United	3	124	74	18	32	251	165	240	1.9355	86	0.6935	0	0
25	Whitley Bay	5	208	63	50	95	273	343	239	1.1490	-70	-0.3365	0	1
26	North Ferriby United	4	168	64	46	58	277	248	238	1.4167	29	0.1726	0	0
27	Lancaster City	3	122	67	31	24	234	128	232	1.9016	106	0.8689	1	0
28	Warrington Town	4	164	60	48	56	243	239	228	1.3902	4	0.0244	0	1
29	Droylsden	3	126	65	30	31	236	171	225	1.7857	65	0.5159	1	0
30	Leek Town	3	126	56	30	40	186	144	198	1.5714	42	0.3333	0	0
31	Curzon Ashton	4	164	51	41	72	247	283	194	1.1829	-36	-0.2195	0	1
32	Flixton	4	168	44	40	84	199	294	172	1.0238	-95	-0.5655	0	1
33	Rossendale United	3	126	42	27	57	180	208	153	1.2143	-28	-0.2222	0	0
34	Burscough	2	84	41	26	17	148	96	149	1.7738	52	0.6190	0	0
35	Atherton Laburnum Rovers	3	124	36	29	59	165	213	137	1.1048	-48	-0.3871	0	1
36	Leigh Genesis	2	82	38	18	26	118	92	132	1.6098	26	0.3171	0	0
37	Bishop Auckland	2	84	27	23	34	119	147	104	1.2381	-28	-0.3333	0	0
38	Goole Town	2	82	27	18	37	124	148	99	1.2073	-24	-0.2927	0	1
39	Whitby Town	1	42	30	8	4	99	48	98	2.3333	51	1.2143	1	0
40	Hucknall Town	1	42	26	11	5	80	38	89	2.1190	42	1.0000	0	0
41	Caernarfon Town	2	82	22	21	39	113	150	87	1.0610	-37	-0.4512	0	0
42	Blyth Spartans	1	42	26	9	7	95	55	87	2.0714	40	0.9524	1	0
43	Accrington Stanley	1	42	25	9	8	96	43	84	2.0000	53	1.2619	1	0
44	Hyde FC	1	42	24	8	10	79	49	80	1.9048	30	0.7143	1	0
45	Mossley	2	82	21	17	44	96	158	80	0.9756	-62	-0.7561	0	1
46	Vauxhall Motors	1	42	23	10	9	95	50	79	1.8810	45	1.0714	0	0
47	Fleetwood Town FC	2	82	19	21	42	92	155	78	0.9512	-63	-0.7683	0	1
48	Kidsgrove Athletic	2	84	19	20	45	94	138	77	0.9167	-44	-0.5238	0	0
49	Gateshead	1	42	21	4	17	64	68	67	1.5952	-4	-0.0952	0	0
50	Bridlington Town	1	42	16	10	16	70	68	58	1.3810	2	0.0476	0	0
51	Prescot Cables	1	42	16	10	16	63	65	58	1.3810	-2	-0.0476	0	0
52	Colwyn Bay	1	42	14	9	19	56	82	51	1.2143	-26	-0.6190	0	0
53	Winsford United	1	42	13	11	18	61	70	50	1.1905	-9	-0.2143	0	1
54	Ossett Albion	1	42	8	8	26	34	99	32	0.7619	-65	-1.5476	0	1
55	Buxton	1	42	7	3	32	41	87	24	0.5714	-46	-1.0952	0	1