The all-time table uses three points for a win and one point for a draw, and does not consider point deductions

Rank	Team	Seasons	G	W	D	L	GF	GA	Pts	Pts/Game	+-	+-/game	Champions	Relegated
1	Matlock Town	18	754	283	176	295	1084	1081	1025	1.3594	3	0.0040	0	0
2	Whitby Town	18	757	279	181	297	1078	1172	1018	1.3448	-94	-0.1242	0	0
3	Ashton United	16	673	269	157	247	1060	1014	964	1.4324	46	0.0684	0	0
4	Marine	16	684	252	172	260	962	965	928	1.3567	-3	-0.0044	0	1
5	Buxton	14	590	245	156	189	941	782	891	1.5102	159	0.2695	1	0
6	Nantwich Town	14	591	230	140	221	938	882	830	1.4044	56	0.0948	0	1
7	Witton Albion	12	501	207	111	183	787	696	732	1.4611	91	0.1816	0	3
8	FC United of Manchester	10	414	212	86	116	782	520	722	1.7440	262	0.6329	1	0
9	Frickley Athletic	13	556	174	142	240	703	875	664	1.1942	-172	-0.3094	0	1
10	Blyth Spartans	7	310	158	69	83	568	391	543	1.7516	177	0.5710	2	0
11	North Ferriby United	9	330	153	67	110	551	458	526	1.5939	93	0.2818	1	1
12	Hednesford Town	8	340	149	75	116	526	461	522	1.5353	65	0.1912	0	0
13	Grantham Town	10	428	130	97	201	574	740	487	1.1379	-166	-0.3879	0	2
14	Rushall Olympic	7	314	135	72	107	483	435	477	1.5191	48	0.1529	0	0
15	Guiseley	7	288	131	65	92	476	369	458	1.5903	107	0.3715	1	0
16	Stafford Rangers	9	379	110	116	153	485	570	446	1.1768	-85	-0.2243	0	1
17	Warrington Town	6	248	125	68	55	399	268	443	1.7863	131	0.5282	0	0
18	Workington	6	266	130	45	91	397	317	435	1.6353	80	0.3008	0	1
19	Worksop Town	7	292	113	62	117	491	502	401	1.3733	-11	-0.0377	0	0
20	Kendal Town	7	288	111	60	117	503	531	393	1.3646	-28	-0.0972	0	1
21	Bradford Park Avenue	5	206	101	41	64	393	293	344	1.6699	100	0.4854	0	1
22	Mickleover Sports	7	291	93	62	136	402	479	341	1.1718	-77	-0.2646	0	1
23	Hyde FC	6	245	95	55	95	362	348	340	1.3878	14	0.0571	1	1
24	Barwell	5	230	94	52	84	336	316	334	1.4522	20	0.0870	0	0
25	Farsley Celtic	4	170	99	35	36	334	184	332	1.9529	150	0.8824	1	0
26	Burscough	6	248	93	48	107	402	417	327	1.3185	-15	-0.0605	1	1
27	Ossett Town	7	288	88	58	142	381	504	322	1.1181	-123	-0.4271	0	1
28	South Shields	4	157	96	31	30	292	154	319	2.0318	138	0.8790	1	0
29	Radcliffe	6	242	78	59	105	298	366	293	1.2107	-68	-0.2810	0	1
30	Stourbridge	4	184	80	44	60	300	242	284	1.5435	58	0.3152	0	0
31	Ilkeston	5	226	76	51	99	319	353	279	1.2345	-34	-0.1504	0	1
32	Lancaster City	5	204	73	52	79	261	281	271	1.3284	-20	-0.0980	0	0
33	Bamber Bridge	5	199	74	36	89	292	345	258	1.2965	-53	-0.2663	0	1
34	Prescot Cables	5	208	67	50	91	264	339	251	1.2067	-75	-0.3606	0	1
35	Chorley	3	130	73	24	33	246	139	243	1.8692	107	0.8231	1	0
36	Gateshead	4	166	66	43	57	281	260	241	1.4518	21	0.1265	0	0
37	Ilkeston Town	4	166	61	51	54	237	219	234	1.4096	18	0.1084	0	0
38	Skelmersdale United	4	184	64	35	85	256	327	227	1.2337	-71	-0.3859	0	1
39	Stalybridge Celtic	5	203	62	40	101	246	325	226	1.1133	-79	-0.3892	0	1
40	Gainsborough Trinity	4	156	60	46	50	220	184	226	1.4487	36	0.2308	0	0
41	Halesowen Town	4	184	56	53	75	203	257	221	1.2011	-54	-0.2935	0	0
42	Leek Town	4	166	54	49	63	216	234	211	1.2711	-18	-0.1084	0	1
43	Stocksbridge Park Steels	5	210	56	42	112	339	454	210	1.0000	-115	-0.5476	0	1
44	Stamford	4	178	53	37	88	261	343	196	1.1011	-82	-0.4607	0	2
45	Scarborough Athletic	3	117	53	26	38	175	151	185	1.5812	24	0.2051	0	0
46	Lincoln United	4	166	44	41	81	181	273	173	1.0422	-92	-0.5542	0	1
47	Eastwood Town	3	124	48	27	49	179	203	171	1.3790	-24	-0.1935	1	1
48	AFC Fylde	2	88	51	15	22	190	92	168	1.9091	98	1.1136	0	0
49	Basford United	3	114	46	23	45	163	155	161	1.4123	8	0.0702	0	0
50	Fleetwood Town	2	82	47	17	18	152	99	158	1.9268	53	0.6463	1	0
51	Morpeth Town	3	111	45	23	43	170	159	158	1.4234	11	0.0991	0	0
52	Northwich Victoria	2	84	44	17	23	139	98	149	1.7738	41	0.4881	0	1
53	Sutton Coldfield Town	3	138	39	28	71	160	253	145	1.0507	-93	-0.6739	0	1
54	AFC Telford United	2	84	35	32	17	126	92	137	1.6310	34	0.4048	0	0
55	Boston United	2	80	35	21	24	128	86	126	1.5750	42	0.5250	0	0
56	Atherton Collieries	3	110	32	27	51	108	151	123	1.1182	-43	-0.3909	0	0
57	Kings Lynn Town	2	92	34	18	40	136	158	120	1.3043	-22	-0.2391	0	0
58	Colwyn Bay	2	88	34	15	39	118	151	117	1.3295	-33	-0.3750	0	1
59	Coalville Town	2	92	30	17	45	141	171	107	1.1630	-30	-0.3261	0	0
60	Chasetown	2	84	30	17	37	126	134	107	1.2738	-8	-0.0952	0	1
61	Darlington 1883	1	46	33	5	8	106	42	104	2.2609	64	1.3913	1	0
62	Trafford	2	92	26	23	43	135	166	101	1.0978	-31	-0.3370	0	1
63	Chester	1	42	31	7	4	102	29	100	2.3810	73	1.7381	1	0
64	FC Halifax Town	1	42	30	8	4	108	36	98	2.3333	72	1.7143	1	0
65	Altrincham	1	46	28	11	7	101	42	95	2.0652	59	1.2826	1	0
66	Wakefield	2	84	25	19	40	98	136	94	1.1190	-38	-0.4524	0	1
67	Salford City	1	46	27	9	10	94	48	90	1.9565	46	1.0000	0	0
68	Hucknall Town	2	80	23	18	39	122	161	87	1.0875	-39	-0.4875	0	1
69	Spennymoor Town	1	46	25	12	9	96	48	87	1.8913	48	1.0435	0	0
70	Curzon Ashton	1	46	23	14	9	79	46	83	1.8043	33	0.7174	0	0
71	Retford United	2	80	23	13	44	104	157	82	1.0250	-53	-0.6625	0	1
72	Shaw Lane	1	46	25	7	14	79	62	82	1.7826	17	0.3696	0	1
73	Ramsbottom United	2	92	20	19	53	109	192	79	0.8587	-83	-0.9022	0	1
74	Belper Town	2	88	13	23	52	106	182	62	0.7045	-76	-0.8636	0	2
75	Warrington Rylands 1906	1	42	17	9	16	64	55	60	1.4286	9	0.2143	0	0
76	Mickleover	1	42	15	10	17	54	65	55	1.3095	-11	-0.2619	0	0
77	Marske United	1	42	15	5	22	57	79	50	1.1905	-22	-0.5238	0	0
78	Cammell Laird	1	42	12	11	19	58	70	47	1.1190	-12	-0.2857	0	1
79	Corby Town	1	46	12	10	24	49	72	46	1.0000	-23	-0.5000	0	1
80	Bishop Auckland	1	42	11	7	24	51	74	40	0.9524	-23	-0.5476	0	1
81	Liversedge	1	42	11	7	24	48	86	40	0.9524	-38	-0.9048	0	1
82	Leigh Genesis	1	42	11	7	24	42	88	40	0.9524	-46	-1.0952	0	1
83	Spennymoor United	1	42	9	10	23	44	65	37	0.8810	-21	-0.5000	0	1
84	Bridlington Town	1	42	7	14	21	44	66	35	0.8333	-22	-0.5238	0	1
85	Mossley	1	42	10	5	27	48	79	35	0.8333	-31	-0.7381	0	1
86	Runcorn	1	42	6	11	25	36	108	29	0.6905	-72	-1.7143	0	1
87	Droylsden	1	46	2	3	41	40	182	9	0.1957	-142	-3.0870	0	1
88	Durham City	1	38	2	0	36	27	168	6	0.1579	-141	-3.7105	0	1
89	Kings Lynn	1	0	0	0	0	0	0	0		0