The all-time table uses three points for a win and one point for a draw, and does not consider point deductions

Rank	Team	Seasons	G	W	D	L	GF	GA	Pts	Pts/Game	+-	+-/game	Champions	Relegated
1	Newton Aycliffe	1	38	27	4	7	102	48	85	2.2368	54	1.4211	1	0
2	Ashington	1	38	25	5	8	79	35	80	2.1053	44	1.1579	0	0
3	Bishop Auckland	1	38	24	6	8	99	48	78	2.0526	51	1.3421	0	0
4	Whitley Bay	1	38	22	7	9	68	55	73	1.9211	13	0.3421	0	0
5	West Allotment Celtic	1	38	21	4	13	74	55	67	1.7632	19	0.5000	0	0
6	Whickham	1	38	18	7	13	56	49	61	1.6053	7	0.1842	0	0
7	Redcar Athletic	1	38	18	7	13	83	70	61	1.6053	13	0.3421	0	0
8	Heaton Stannington	1	38	18	5	15	81	62	59	1.5526	19	0.5000	0	0
9	Guisborough Town	1	38	16	9	13	69	54	57	1.5000	15	0.3947	0	0
10	Newcastle Benfield	1	38	14	11	13	67	57	53	1.3947	10	0.2632	0	0
11	West Auckland Town	1	38	12	11	15	65	65	47	1.2368	0	0.0000	0	0
12	Tow Law Town	1	38	14	4	20	59	84	46	1.2105	-25	-0.6579	0	0
13	Crook Town	1	38	14	2	22	52	77	44	1.1579	-25	-0.6579	0	0
14	Penrith	1	38	11	8	19	45	64	41	1.0789	-19	-0.5000	0	0
15	Carlisle City	1	38	10	10	18	57	68	40	1.0526	-11	-0.2895	0	0
16	Sunderland RCA	1	38	11	5	22	43	94	38	1.0000	-51	-1.3421	0	1
17	Northallerton Town	1	38	10	8	20	53	73	38	1.0000	-20	-0.5263	0	0
18	Seaham Red Star	1	38	9	9	20	46	61	36	0.9474	-15	-0.3947	0	0
19	Pickering Town	1	38	11	3	24	45	94	36	0.9474	-49	-1.2895	0	0
20	Thornaby	1	38	9	7	22	42	72	34	0.8947	-30	-0.7895	0	1