The all-time table uses three points for a win and one point for a draw, and does not consider point deductions

Rank	Team	Seasons	G	W	D	L	GF	GA	Pts	Pts/Game	+-	+-/game	Champions	Relegated
1	Charlotte Eagles	3	60	32	12	16	113	76	108	1.8000	37	0.6167	0	0
2	Harrisburg City Islanders	3	60	31	13	16	103	74	106	1.7667	29	0.4833	1	0
3	Western Mass Pioneers	3	60	28	13	19	97	76	97	1.6167	21	0.3500	0	0
4	Richmond Kickers	2	40	25	9	6	87	35	84	2.1000	52	1.3000	0	0
5	Wilmington Hammerheads	3	60	20	16	24	97	84	76	1.2667	13	0.2167	0	0
6	Cincinnati Kings	3	60	20	13	27	85	91	73	1.2167	-6	-0.1000	0	0
7	New Hampshire Phantoms	3	60	18	9	33	72	115	63	1.0500	-43	-0.7167	0	0
8	Pittsburgh Riverhounds	2	40	14	9	17	59	45	51	1.2750	14	0.3500	0	0
9	Cleveland City Stars	1	19	10	8	1	31	14	38	2.0000	17	0.8947	0	0
10	Long Island Rough Riders	2	40	10	5	25	44	82	35	0.8750	-38	-0.9500	0	0
11	Crystal Palace Baltimore	1	20	9	5	6	27	20	32	1.6000	7	0.3500	0	0
12	Bermuda Hogges	1	20	3	3	14	16	45	12	0.6000	-29	-1.4500	0	0
13	Northern Virginia Royals	1	20	2	0	18	16	90	6	0.3000	-74	-3.7000	0	0